Vacuum cleaners: tell me where I'm wrong

Buy Me Once Longevity Awards - the repairer's review. About 10 minutes. Everything saves as you go, so you can come back to it.

Before you see my table

Three quick ones first - your gut answer, before my numbers can nudge it.

Please answer all three - they're the most valuable answers in here.

Fault 1 of 6

Motor fails (carbon brushes, bearings, armature, thermal burnout)

Out of 10 broken vacuum cleaners that come to you, how many have this fault?

Hardly everNearly all of them

Tap a number

If a vacuum cleaner came in with this fault, what would the repair be like?

Think of the cost of the fix against the price of a new one - not whether the owner wanted it fixed.

Quick, cheap fixWorth repairingCosts more than it's worth

Tap a number

"Our estimate" is where we've got it from desk research. Tap it if you agree, or tap your own number.

Fault 2 of 6

Switch / control electronics (switches, speed PCB, sensors)

Out of 10 broken vacuum cleaners that come to you, how many have this fault?

Hardly everNearly all of them

Tap a number

If a vacuum cleaner came in with this fault, what would the repair be like?

Think of the cost of the fix against the price of a new one - not whether the owner wanted it fixed.

Quick, cheap fixWorth repairingCosts more than it's worth

Tap a number

"Our estimate" is where we've got it from desk research. Tap it if you agree, or tap your own number.

Fault 3 of 6

Suction loss / blockage / filter clogging

Out of 10 broken vacuum cleaners that come to you, how many have this fault?

Hardly everNearly all of them

Tap a number

If a vacuum cleaner came in with this fault, what would the repair be like?

Think of the cost of the fix against the price of a new one - not whether the owner wanted it fixed.

Quick, cheap fixWorth repairingCosts more than it's worth

Tap a number

"Our estimate" is where we've got it from desk research. Tap it if you agree, or tap your own number.

Fault 4 of 6

Cord / plug / cable-rewind

Out of 10 broken vacuum cleaners that come to you, how many have this fault?

Hardly everNearly all of them

Tap a number

If a vacuum cleaner came in with this fault, what would the repair be like?

Think of the cost of the fix against the price of a new one - not whether the owner wanted it fixed.

Quick, cheap fixWorth repairingCosts more than it's worth

Tap a number

"Our estimate" is where we've got it from desk research. Tap it if you agree, or tap your own number.

Fault 5 of 6

Brush bar / belt / powered floor head

Out of 10 broken vacuum cleaners that come to you, how many have this fault?

Hardly everNearly all of them

Tap a number

If a vacuum cleaner came in with this fault, what would the repair be like?

Think of the cost of the fix against the price of a new one - not whether the owner wanted it fixed.

Quick, cheap fixWorth repairingCosts more than it's worth

Tap a number

"Our estimate" is where we've got it from desk research. Tap it if you agree, or tap your own number.

Fault 6 of 6

Hose, wand, body, wheels and catches

Out of 10 broken vacuum cleaners that come to you, how many have this fault?

Hardly everNearly all of them

Tap a number

If a vacuum cleaner came in with this fault, what would the repair be like?

Think of the cost of the fix against the price of a new one - not whether the owner wanted it fixed.

Quick, cheap fixWorth repairingCosts more than it's worth

Tap a number

"Our estimate" is where we've got it from desk research. Tap it if you agree, or tap your own number.

Last three on the faults

Which fault did I get most wrong?

Is a big one missing?

What never reaches you?

You only see the vacuum cleaners someone thought were worth bringing in. Which faults do you think mostly end up in the bin instead - so they're rarer on your bench than in real life?

Tap a number on both scales first.

Brands - from the bench, not reputation

A few claims from my research

1. On a typical corded vacuum, blocked airflow (full bag/clogged filter) is the main root cause behind motor burnout via overheating and carbon-brush wear.

2. A Numatic Henry's carbon brushes and motor can be replaced by a competent owner with a screwdriver, and parts remain readily available.

3. A passive (non-powered) floor head fails far less often than a belt-driven or motorised brush roll on an upright.

How should I credit you?

Named: "verified by [you], [business]" on the awards page, and listed as a recommended repairer. Anonymous: "independent repairer, [n] years". Your call - some fixers would rather not be seen rating brands they also fix under warranty.

Name, email and a credit choice please.